Skip to content
R&D Tax Academy
Contact us

How R&D advisor fee structures work, and the questions to ask before you sign

Contingent, fixed or hourly: each fee model rewards different behaviour. Understanding what you are being offered is the first step to buying advice on fair terms.

Published 02 Oct 2026 · 9 min read

Advisory fees for R&D claims vary enormously, and claimants are rarely shown how the structures compare. That matters because the fee model shapes the advice. An advisor paid a percentage of the benefit has an incentive to make the claim larger; an advisor paid by the hour has an incentive to make it slower; an advisor paid a fixed fee has an incentive to make it quick. None of these is wrong in itself. The point is to know which incentive you are buying, and to write down what happens if the claim is later reduced under review.

What this guide covers

  • The four fee models and what each one rewards.
  • What actually drives the cost of preparing a claim.
  • Warning signs in a proposal and the questions to ask before you sign.
  • What an engagement needs to cover in each of the seven countries, and where the advisor is named on the claim.

The main models

Contingent (percentage of benefit)

The advisor takes a share of the benefit obtained. Attractive because there is nothing to pay if the claim fails, and cash flow is preserved. The risks are that the percentage can be large relative to the work involved, that the incentive is to maximise rather than to get it right, and that the advisor may or may not stand behind the claim if it is later reduced under review. Ask what happens to the fee if the claim is reduced or repaid, and whether the percentage steps down for larger claims. Rules on contingent fees for tax work differ by jurisdiction and professional body; the United States position is set out under Country differences below, and in every country you should ask which professional body the advisor belongs to and what its rules say.

Fixed fee

A price agreed up front for a defined scope. Predictable, and the incentive is to do the work efficiently. The risk is scope: make sure the fee covers support during a review, not just filing the claim, and that it covers any step the scheme requires before the claim, such as a notification, registration or approval.

Hourly or time-based

Common with accounting firms and for complex or first-year claims. Transparent if the estimate is realistic and updated. Ask for a cap or an estimate with a notification threshold.

Hybrid

A reduced fixed fee plus a smaller contingent element, or a fixed fee for preparation and hourly for review support. Often a reasonable balance, provided the components are written down.

ModelWhat you payWhat it rewardsMain riskFirst question to ask
ContingentA share of the benefit obtainedA larger claimOver-claiming; the fee may not follow the claim down if it is reducedWhat happens to the fee if the claim is reduced or repaid?
Fixed feeAn agreed price for a defined scopeSpeed and efficiencyScope gaps, especially review support and pre-claim stepsExactly what is inside the scope, and what is extra?
HourlyTime at agreed ratesThoroughness, and time spentCost overrun without warningWhat is the estimate, and at what point will you tell us it is changing?
HybridA mix, usually fixed plus a smaller contingent or hourly partA balance of the aboveUnclear componentsCan each component be written as a separate line in the engagement letter?

What drives the cost

Whatever the model, the work is the same: identifying projects, interviewing technical staff, drafting descriptions, gathering cost data, calculating, filing, and supporting any review. Fees should reflect the complexity of your projects and the quality of your records, not simply the size of the benefit. A company with good records made at the time should expect to pay less, and to be told why.

Warning signs

  • A quote based only on your turnover or headcount, before anyone has asked about the technical work.
  • An assurance that "everything qualifies" or that review is unlikely.
  • No mention of what happens if the claim is challenged.
  • Reluctance to name who will sign the claim or to be named on it, where the scheme requires it.
  • Pressure to file before your own technical team has reviewed the description.
  • A proposal that does not mention the step the scheme requires before the claim, where there is one.

Questions to ask before you sign

  1. How is the fee calculated, and what is the estimated amount in money terms?
  2. What is included: preparation only, or also responding to a review?
  3. What happens to the fee if the claim is reduced, withdrawn or repaid?
  4. Who does the technical work, and what is their background in our field?
  5. Will our technical staff review and approve the description before filing?
  6. What records will you need from us, and what will you keep on file?
  7. Can we see an anonymised example of the claim documents you produce?
  8. Are you willing to be named on the claim where the tax authority asks for it?
  9. Which professional body are you a member of, and what do its rules say about the fee model you are proposing?

Independent benchmarks

knowyourfees.org publishes independent guidance on fee structures for R&D claims and the questions to ask before you engage an advisor. Read it before you take a proposal, not after. The guide to briefing and evaluating an R&D tax advisor covers how to compare proposals once you have them.

Doing some of it yourself

Many companies keep project identification and documentation in-house and engage an advisor only for calculation and filing, or for review support. That reduces fees and improves the claim, because the people who know the work are the ones describing it. The In-House Finance Team Program covers how to set that up.

Illustrative example

Illustrative example. Marrow Analytics, a hypothetical company, has eligible costs of 500,000 and receives three proposals. The first is contingent: one fifth of the benefit, with nothing said about review. The second is a fixed fee of 20,000 covering preparation and filing only. The third is hourly, estimated at 25,000 with a cap and a clause that review support is charged separately. Suppose the benefit at that country's rate is 100,000. All three cost roughly the same on the day of filing: 20,000, 20,000 and up to 25,000. The differences appear later. If a reviewer reduces the claim to 60,000, the contingent fee falls to 12,000 only if the engagement letter says so; some letters fix the fee at the amount originally claimed. The fixed fee advisor will charge again for the review unless the scope said otherwise. The hourly advisor's cap does not apply to the review. Marrow's finance director goes back to all three with the same two questions: what is the fee if the claim is reduced, and what does review support cost. The answers, not the headline numbers, decide the engagement.

Country differences

Fee models are a matter of contract everywhere. What differs is whether the scheme names the advisor on the claim, whether a step before the claim must be inside the scope, and in one country whether a contingent fee is permitted at all. Each country page holds the detail.

  • United States. Treasury Circular 230 section 10.27 restricts practitioners from charging a contingent fee for services rendered in connection with any matter before the Internal Revenue Service, with stated exceptions (examination of or challenge to an original return or an amended return or claim for refund filed within 120 days of a written notice of examination, claims for refund of interest or penalties, and judicial proceedings). In Ridgely v. Lew, 55 F. Supp. 3d 89 (D.D.C. 2014), the United States District Court for the District of Columbia held that the IRS lacked statutory authority to regulate contingent fee arrangements for the preparation and filing of ordinary refund claims, meaning refund claims prepared and filed before the IRS has begun an examination of the return, so section 10.27 is not enforced against those claims. The AICPA Code of Professional Conduct, rule 1.510.001, provides that a member in public practice shall not prepare an original or amended tax return or claim for a tax refund for a contingent fee for any client; interpretation 1.510.010 gives examples where a contingent fee is permitted, including representing a client in connection with a revenue agent's examination. Official sources: 31 CFR 10.27 and the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct. See How to claim: United States.
  • United Kingdom. The additional information form requires the details of any agent who advised on the claim and the senior officer of the company responsible for it. A company cannot show reasonable care merely by appointing an agent; it must take reasonable steps to check the return. See Additional information form: United Kingdom.
  • Ireland. Companies claiming for the first time, or that have not claimed in the previous 3 years, must notify Revenue in advance, at least 90 days before the claim, using a prescribed form, so the scope must start well before the return. Revenue may consult any person it considers has expertise in the field to determine whether the activities are research and development activities. See How to claim: Ireland.
  • Canada. Form T661 includes Part 9, claim preparer information. Where claim preparer information required on Form T661 is missing or incomplete, a penalty of C$1,000 applies, for which the claimant and the claim preparer are jointly and severally liable. See Form T661: Canada.
  • Australia. Register R&D activities with the department within 10 months of the end of the income year, then claim the offset in the company tax return; the customer portal is accessed with myID, by the company or an authorised tax agent or R&D consultant. A scope that covers only the tax return misses the registration. See Registration with AusIndustry: Australia.
  • New Zealand. Approval comes before the claim: general approval, or criteria and methodologies approval, for the income year, then the supplementary return. Applications and returns are filed through the research and development tax incentive account in myIR. See General approval: New Zealand.
  • Singapore. No registration. Claim the enhanced deduction in the corporate income tax return by its filing due date; IRAS requires an R&D claim form for larger R&D claims, giving project descriptions and a breakdown of expenditure. See How to claim: Singapore.

Educational material, not advice. Fee arrangements are a matter of contract; take advice on any agreement before signing.

Educational content only, not tax advice. Rules change and eligibility depends on your circumstances, so check the official guidance or speak to a qualified advisor before you claim. See the disclaimer.