Skip to content
R&D Tax Academy
Contact us

Common R&D claim mistakes and how to avoid them

The same handful of errors appear in weak claims under every scheme. Most are avoidable with a little structure. Here are the ones that matter, why they matter, and what to do instead.

Published 02 Oct 2026 · 9 min read

Claims rarely fail on a subtle misreading of the law. They fail for ordinary reasons: the project was not really R&D, the evidence was not kept, the numbers were built backwards from a target, or a deadline was missed. The pattern is the same under all seven schemes covered here, and each of these failures is avoidable.

What this guide covers

  • The nine mistakes that recur in weak claims, and why each matters to a reviewer.
  • The step before the claim and the claim deadline in each of the seven schemes.
  • The headline rule on contracted-out and overseas work in each scheme.
  • What to do instead.

Claiming the whole project instead of the uncertain part

A software product, a new production line or a building design may contain genuine R&D, but the R&D is usually a fraction of the whole. Claiming every hour because "the project was innovative" is the most common way to overstate a claim. Identify the specific technical uncertainty, draw a boundary around the work that addressed it, and claim that.

Routine work presented as development

Installing and configuring purchased systems, applying known techniques to a new customer, testing for quality control, and cosmetic redesign do not qualify under any of the seven schemes, however skilled the people doing them. The test is whether a competent professional in the field would have known how to do it. If yes, it is not R&D, even if it was hard work.

Reconstructing uncertainty after success

Once a problem is solved it looks obvious, and a description written at year end tends to describe the solution rather than the uncertainty. Reviewers recognise these quickly. The fix is a dated note at project start that says what the team did not know how to do; see the guide to what reviewers look for in records made at the time.

No time records

Staff costs are the largest part of most claims and the easiest to challenge. A percentage assigned in hindsight with no supporting record is a common cause of reductions. Monthly allocation signed by a team lead is enough; annual guesses are not.

Building the numbers backwards

Deciding the target benefit first and then finding costs to fit it produces claims that do not reconcile to the ledger and cannot be defended line by line. Start from the ledger and payroll, allocate to projects, and let the benefit be whatever it is.

Missing an administrative deadline

Every scheme has hard deadlines, and several have a step before the claim. Missing one can void an otherwise sound claim.

  • United States. No pre-registration. Form 6765 is filed with the income tax return. A claim for credit or refund must be filed within three years from the time the return was filed or two years from the time the tax was paid, whichever is later, and a refund claim must identify the business components, the activities and the QRE totals. See Deadlines: United States.
  • United Kingdom. Claim notification if you are claiming for the first time or your last claim was more than 3 years ago, within 6 months of the end of the period of account, and an additional information form with every claim. The claim must be made, amended or withdrawn within 2 years of the end of the accounting period. See Deadlines: United Kingdom.
  • Ireland. Companies claiming for the first time, or that have not claimed in the previous 3 years, must notify Revenue in advance, at least 90 days before the claim, using a prescribed form. The claim is made within 12 months of the end of the accounting period in which the expenditure was incurred. See Deadlines: Ireland.
  • Canada. No registration. The claim is filed with the income tax return and no later than 12 months after its filing due date; an expenditure not identified on the prescribed form by the reporting deadline cannot earn an investment tax credit. See Deadlines: Canada.
  • Australia. Register R&D activities with the department within 10 months of the end of the income year, then claim the offset in the company tax return; late applications without an extension are refused. See Deadlines: Australia.
  • New Zealand. Apply for general approval by the last day of the 3rd month after the end of the income year, then file the supplementary return within 30 days after the income tax return due date. See Deadlines: New Zealand.
  • Singapore. No registration. Claim the enhanced deduction in the corporate income tax return by its filing due date. See Deadlines: Singapore.

Subcontractor and overseas costs claimed without checking the rules

Rules on who can claim contracted-out work, how much of a payment qualifies, and whether work done abroad counts differ sharply between countries; the linked pages hold the conditions and exceptions.

CountryContracted-out workWork done abroad
United StatesContract research: 65% of amounts paid for qualified research performed for youResearch conducted outside the United States is excluded; contract research expenses qualify only to the extent the research is conducted within the United States
United Kingdom65 percent of payments to an unconnected subcontractor for contracted out R&D qualifyFor accounting periods beginning on or after 1 April 2024, relief for contracted out R&D and externally provided workers is generally limited to work carried out in the UK
IrelandWork by an unconnected person on behalf of the company qualifies up to the greater of 15 percent of the company's own qualifying expenditure and €100,000, provided the person does not also claimExpenditure qualifies where the R&D activities are carried on within the State or another EEA state, and is not relieved against tax in another territory
CanadaOnly 80 percent of arm's length contract payments and third-party payments for SR&ED are included in qualified expendituresSalary or wages for SR&ED carried on outside Canada by employees resident in Canada can be included up to 10 percent of the total salary or wages for SR&ED carried on in Canada in the year
AustraliaExpenditure is not eligible where the R&D activities are conducted to a significant extent for another entityR&D activities conducted outside Australia are eligible only where covered by an Overseas Finding
New ZealandExpenditure on a contractor performing R&D on behalf of the claimant is eligible for the claimant; the contractor cannot claim for the same activitiesEligible expenditure on R&D performed outside New Zealand is limited to 10 percent of the total eligible expenditure for the year
SingaporeFor R&D outsourced to an R&D organisation in Singapore, IRAS treats a fixed portion of the fee (60 percent) as qualifying staff costs and consumablesR&D undertaken outside Singapore is deductible at 100 percent where related to the trade, and does not qualify for the additional deductions

Nobody technical reviewed the claim

Claims written entirely by finance or by an external advisor without sign-off from the people who did the work contain errors the technical team would spot in minutes. Build a fifteen-minute review with the technical lead into the process.

Treating the advisor's fee as the only cost

A claim that is reduced under review costs interest, possibly penalties, and weeks of management time. Understand the fee structure you are being offered and what it rewards; the independent guidance at knowyourfees.org is a good starting point.

What to do instead

Boundary the uncertainty, date the evidence, allocate time monthly, reconcile costs to the ledger, check the contractor and overseas rules, put the deadlines in the finance calendar, and have the technical lead sign off. None of this is difficult; the claims that survive review are the ones that followed a process.

Illustrative example

Illustrative example. Brightwater Composites Ltd, a hypothetical company, spends 800,000 in a year developing a new panel line and claims the whole amount because the product is new to the market. There is no project note and time is allocated at year end as a single percentage. The reviewer asks what the team did not know how to do at the outset. The honest answer is that the only genuine uncertainty was a resin cure problem that cost about 200,000; the rest was tooling, installation and training using known methods. The claim is reduced to a quarter, the benefit is recalculated at that country's rate on 200,000, and the company pays interest on the difference. The following year the company writes the project note at project start, signs monthly allocations, and claims 250,000 of a 900,000 programme. The claim is smaller, and it is the one that stands.

Country differences

The mistakes are the same everywhere; what the reviewer tests first differs.

  • United States. IRS examiners are directed to test contemporaneous documentation, the basis of wage allocations and the consistency between technical narratives and financial records. See Reviews and audits: United States.
  • United Kingdom. HMRC selects R&D claims for compliance checks on a risk basis using the information on the additional information form and other data. A company cannot show reasonable care merely by appointing an agent. See HMRC compliance checks: United Kingdom.
  • Ireland. Revenue expects contemporaneous documentation for the science test, including evidence of the uncertainty, the advancement sought and the systematic investigation, and for the accounting test, including timesheets or equivalent records, invoices and a reconciliation of the claim to the accounts. See Revenue audits: Ireland.
  • Canada. Factors in selecting claims for review include the claimant's history, the size and change in the claim, the sector, the claim preparer, and the quality and consistency of the information on Form T661. See CRA reviews: Canada.
  • Australia. Joint guidance and taxpayer alerts identify risk areas including software development claimed at a project level, ordinary business activities, expenditure not at risk, overseas activities without an Overseas Finding, associate payments and interposed entities. See ATO and DISE reviews: Australia.
  • New Zealand. Inland Revenue has identified common reasons for declining activities, including the absence of scientific or technological uncertainty, descriptions of business objectives rather than R&D, excluded activities and insufficient detail on the systematic approach. See Inland Revenue reviews: New Zealand.
  • Singapore. IRAS may request further information on R&D claims before finalising the assessment, including project descriptions and the expenditure breakdown. See Reviews and audits: Singapore.

Educational material, not advice. Eligibility, deadlines and treatment depend on the scheme and the facts.

Educational content only, not tax advice. Rules change and eligibility depends on your circumstances, so check the official guidance or speak to a qualified advisor before you claim. See the disclaimer.